This week I have some things to say, both good and bad. That means this'll be quite a long post, so I will try to organize it so you can skip to whichever part you wish.
READING: The Good and Bad of Artemis FowlThis week, I read Artemis Fowl: The Last Guardian. I want to both murder Eoin Colfer and hug him. He did my ultimate taboo in the realm of writing.
Bringing back the dead.
There are some times (very rarely) when bringing back a dead character is done correctly, with class and sophistication. But most of the time it is done to spare the readers of having to lose a beloved of humorous character. I cannot count on my hands the number of time characters have come back from a perfectly acceptable death. Goku can fill one of my hands himself, dying to save the world constantly then being wished back to life with the Dragonballs. It gives the reader some closure, but the effect diminishes the legitimacy of the writing. Leo Tolstoy never brought HIS characters back to life. Andrew Bolonski died and stayed dead.But I can forgive him because against all odds he didn't make a romance plot. Through the series, Artemis and Holly get progressively closer even sharing a kiss once. But Artemis is a human and Holly is a fairy. Fans everywhere have been planning and scheming, trying to determine how Colfer would make this relationship work. Thankfully, even though it left a hole where my heart is, Colfer kept Artemis a human and Holly a fairy. I'm proud of him. It made it a mature piece of writing.
Artemis Fowl is kind of a disappointment in this book. I wish he would pull out a brilliant plan or have some brilliant thought, but he continually disappointed me. All his plans failed, except for his final one. When he ends up killing himself, he succeeds. D'Arvit.
Foaly was a more inspirational character. He goes out and saves his wife! He drives to his house and stops a goblin mob. It was heartwarming.
Mulch was stealing from Fowl Manor, making me lose all respect I had given him. I thought he would at least be loyal enough to leave Artemis alone (Artemis should have known) or at least not that stupid.
Holly was Holly, she was an awesome pilot, she fought, she made witty comments. Good ol' Holly Short.
Butler...lost something in this book. This character was always substantial, solid, completely loyal and practically infallible. Now he has fears, he falls easily, he questions Artemis. The whole definition of what made Butler was lost. I missed it.
Overall, it wasn't as great as the first book (I love that book). The writing and style didn't change. It was a perfect blend of narration, description, and hilarity. But the plot, the characterization, the enjoyment suffered. It made me fell conflicted between loving the original characters as they were and hating the characters as they are. I questioned the whole series and it felt like a glass shattering against the floor. I reread the first book and it was just as amazing as I remember (Maybe even better) but this last book in the series left a bitter aftertaste that pushes me into the darkest crevice of the internet to get some sort of hit to feel the high I once felt for this series. (What an odd analogy...) I think Colfer gave up. He had more ideas and more stories, but he needed to finish this arc. I wish he had put more heart into it, I wish he had made a beautiful insightful ending, but I can understand the drag 7 sequels must have on a writer. I can understand, but my faith in Colfer is crushed and I don't think I'll ever view him as well as I once did.
TELEVISION: Elementary *Spoilers*
What can I say? That it was terrible? That it was the bane of my existence? That I would rather gouge my eyes out, climb in a car, and run over a basket of kittens than watch this show again?
No, this doesn't quite do justice to the unmitigated hatred I have for this show.
Am I biased? Yes, I've seen real acting in BBC Sherlock and I can't come back. But I tried to come in with an open mind. It snapped close like a bear trap closing in on an unknowing and clueless rabbit. The episode starts with Joan Watson (Yes, our BAMF, male, British, Army doctor has been replaced with a Emotional, female, Asian, former doctor-turned companion) running towards the rehab center to pick up our main character. He escaped. So Joan calls his father and arrives at Sherlock's house to see a lady walk out. (At this point I was face-palming) Joan then proceeds to have an incredibly awkward scene with Sherlock, where he quotes a creepy love quote from the television for no apparent reason... It was just uncomfortable...
I won't explain the entire episode, it was long and boring and stupid, but I will emphasized key points to explain why I hate it so much. I'll even use a list.
1. Sherlock
I've read the original works by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and I feel like I have some credibility in determining if a character was portrayed correctly. Sherlock was smart, odd and good at his job, but he wasn't Sherlock. I have nothing against the actor, i'm sure he has done lovely work outside this, but almost nothing was Sherlock about this character. He was pinning for a girl, had temper tantrums, didn't really deduce like a proper detective, and he apologized readily. He takes Watson's car and crashes it in his frustrations. I couldn't understand why they put that in. It wasn't brilliant, or gentlemanly. He was just odd overall, being everywhere at once and having too much emotion, too many open issues for it to be the real Sherlock Holmes.
2. Watson
Ignoring the fact she's a woman, Watson wasn't Watson. She was offended easily, she wasn't in the military, she was overly concerned with death (the real Watson killed in Afghanistan, he was made of sterner stuff), she was unhappy most of the time, she was there out of obligation rather than an emotional connection. I didn't see Watson at all. Most of his characterization was very British in nature, tea, journal, and admiration for his companion. I didn't see anything like that in Joan.
3. The crime
It was convoluted. Absolutely crazy. Try and follow.
~ Husband becomes Psychiatrist to a violent man who assaults red heads of a certain look.
~ Husband convinces beautiful Wife to get plastic surgery to become a red head.
~ Husband hires Violent man to delivery flowers in hopes that he'll become obsessed with his Wife.
~ Husband gives Violent man steroids instead of prescription drugs.
~ Violent man records psychiatrist's sessions on phone
~ Violent man kills wife
~ Husband kills Violent man, can't find phone
Oops. There are so many plot holes I'm not even going to try and fill them all.
4. Supporting characters
There were none. End of story. They spouted one or two lines and then they were completely forgotten. It made it a very emotionless episode.
5. the Deductions
They were accurate, and kind of clever, but not very Sherlock. He was just jumping around and lying on the floor. There wasn't any observation or small things that the real Sherlock deduced off of. There was no dirt on sleeves, or dog hair, or deduction based on looks. It was all easy things I could have figured out. The amount of glass was more than one (There was two bottoms), the slant in the floor leads to a heavy room, the room was symmetrical so the one thing not symmetrical is missing. Silly thing that most normal people can figure out. Then he goes off and predicts a baseball game which is impossible.
6. The Writing
Non of the dialog, the action, or the plot was engaging. They were dull, boring, obvious or impossible. No one was inspirational, no one was relate-able, no one was thoughtful or insightful. It was just blah. I can't even quote anything in the episode. It was boring.
So I would not recommend this to anyone you like. It wasn't redeemable as a Sherlock spoof, it wasn't redeemable as another cops show. It was boring and disappointing.
Honorable Mention of the Week: DailyBreak
Want to win prizes? Want to earn tones of money? Do you know things? Join DailyBreak. It's fun, easy, free, and I'm using it to help get money for college. Why not try? It is fun, I did a competition based on fantasy novels that I passed with flying colors. One was even for grammar Nazis. Worth a try.